A Push for Safer Toys Aims to Prevent Thousands of Emergency Room Visits Due to Battery-Related Injuries
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) is taking a significant step towards improving the safety of children’s toys by proposing new rules concerning small batteries. Button-cell and coin-cell batteries, frequently found in children’s toys and household items, have been the cause of numerous injuries and even deaths, particularly among young children. The CPSC is now seeking to enforce stricter regulations to mitigate these dangers.
Between 2010 and 2019, over 70,000 emergency room visits in the U.S. were attributed to incidents involving these small batteries, with the vast majority of cases stemming from children swallowing them. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, approximately 90% of battery-related ER visits were caused by ingestion. The remaining cases involved batteries being inserted into children’s noses (5.7%), ears (2.5%), or mouths (1.8%). These incidents often result in serious injuries due to the chemical reaction caused by the battery’s contact with bodily fluids, which can lead to burns, internal damage, and in severe cases, death.
In response to this alarming trend, the CPSC has introduced a detailed proposal that seeks to enforce better labeling on products containing these small batteries. The proposal emphasizes the need for clear, prominent warning labels that caution parents and caregivers about the potential dangers of swallowing batteries. The labels will explicitly state the risks, including the possibility of death if the batteries are ingested. In addition to labeling, the CPSC’s proposal also calls for manufacturers to conduct more rigorous stress-testing of products that use button-cell and coin-cell batteries to ensure that the batteries are securely enclosed and inaccessible to children.
The CPSC’s proposed rule is currently open for public comment until October 15, 2024. Once the public comment period ends, the agency will issue its final mandatory standards, which will be enforceable under federal law. Companies that manufacture products containing these batteries will be required to comply with the new standards within six months of their enactment, allowing time for third-party testing to certify compliance.
Although the proposed changes may lead to a one-time packaging redesign cost and potential alterations to product components, the CPSC does not anticipate a significant financial impact on small businesses. The primary goal of the regulation is to make products safer for children while minimizing the potential burden on manufacturers.
The Dangers of Button-Cell and Coin-Cell Batteries
While these small batteries are ubiquitous in children’s toys, household electronics, and even medical devices, they pose a serious threat to young children. The smooth, shiny appearance of button-cell and coin-cell batteries makes them particularly appealing to infants and toddlers, who often explore their surroundings by putting objects in their mouths. Once swallowed, these batteries can become lodged in the esophagus or digestive tract, where they generate an electrical current that causes a chemical reaction. This reaction can burn through tissue, causing severe internal injuries within just two hours.
Aside from the risk of ingestion, children are also at risk of injury from inserting these batteries into their noses, ears, or other body cavities. The chemical reaction can cause painful burns, infections, and permanent damage if not promptly treated. Given the small size of these batteries, parents may not immediately realize their child has swallowed or inserted one until symptoms like drooling, coughing, vomiting, or wheezing begin to appear—by which time significant damage may already have occurred.
Legal Recourse for Injuries Related to Defective Toys
Families affected by the dangers posed by these small batteries may have grounds to file a lawsuit seeking damages. Product liability lawsuits are often pursued when a product’s design or manufacture leads to injury, and a company can be held accountable for placing an unreasonably dangerous product in the hands of consumers. In the case of toys containing button-cell or coin-cell batteries, families may be able to seek compensation if it is determined that the product was defective, lacked proper safety warnings, or failed to adequately safeguard children from the risks associated with battery exposure.
In a product liability case, the injured party must typically prove that the product in question was defective in its design, manufacture, or marketing. A defect in design means that the product’s blueprint inherently poses a danger, while a manufacturing defect implies an error in the product’s assembly. Marketing defects occur when a product lacks adequate warnings or instructions that could have prevented injury. The new CPSC regulations, when implemented, could set a standard that makes it easier for consumers to hold manufacturers accountable for failing to comply with safety measures.
The Lawsuit Process and the Need for Legal Assistance
Filing a product liability lawsuit can be complex and time-consuming, particularly for individuals unfamiliar with legal procedures. The process typically begins with gathering evidence, such as medical records, proof of purchase, and expert testimony to establish a connection between the product and the injury. Next, the injured party or their attorney files a claim against the manufacturer, distributor, or retailer of the defective product. The case may go through several stages, including discovery (the exchange of information between parties), settlement negotiations, and possibly a trial if a settlement cannot be reached.
Given the intricacies of product liability law and the burden of proof required to succeed in a lawsuit, it is crucial for individuals seeking compensation to work with an experienced attorney. A knowledgeable lawyer can guide victims through each step of the process, ensuring that all necessary documentation is filed correctly and on time. Additionally, legal counsel can negotiate with manufacturers and insurance companies to seek fair compensation for medical expenses, pain and suffering, lost wages, and other damages resulting from the injury.
Recoverable Damages in a Product Liability Case
Victims of injuries caused by defective products, including toys with unsafe battery components, may be entitled to several types of compensation. Economic damages, such as medical bills, rehabilitation costs, and lost wages, are typically recoverable. In cases where the injury has resulted in long-term disability or disfigurement, compensation for future medical expenses and loss of earning capacity may also be sought.
In addition to economic damages, non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, and loss of quality of life, can be awarded. If the manufacturer’s actions were particularly egregious—such as knowingly selling a dangerous product without proper safety measures—punitive damages may also be awarded to punish the company and deter similar behavior in the future.
.svg){kind=small}
.avif)
.avif)